The Best Engagement Ring Shops on Etsy 2023

Engagement ring shopping on Etsy is so much fun! With so much selection, amazing photos, creative designs, and unique stones, I can't get enough of it. There are so many beautiful rings to drool over, and the ability to ask for customization makes Etsy my favorite place to shop for an engagement ring online. I have researched and found the best engagement ring shops on Etsy for the year 2023. 

All of my favorite shops meet these requirements:

• Over 1000 sales
• Over 500 5-star reviews
• Over 3000 people have them as a favorite shop

The 15 Best Engagment Ring Shops on Etsy 2023

Eidel Precious - Toronto, Ontario

Over 6500 sales and 1300 reviews

I love her use of colored sapphires and rose gold, her jewelry is so feminine and lovely. Prices for engagement rings are in the thousands of dollars range. 

Stunningly beautiful sapphire engagement rings. Eidel Precious has been selling rings on Etsy since 2008. The shop owner, Eidel invented the term, "peach champagne sapphires" and was the first to introduce the stones to North America. 

Eidel Precious has over 1300 reviews and 40,000 fans who have favorited the shop on Etsy!

Refund Policy

• You have 7 days to ask for a refund, no questions asked. 

Shipping

• Eidel Precious offers free shipping on most items. 

Warranty 

• 2 year warranty - in case of damage to the setting or small stones, they will repair the ring for free, but it does not cover the central stone. 

Minimal VS -  Ljubljana, Slovenia

Over 33,000 sales and 4000 reviews

 I am in LOVE with this jewelry....it's absolutely breathtaking. The unique shapes, variety of stacking rings, use of colors and alternative gemstones is stunning. Prices are in the thousands of dollars. 

Minimal VS makes elegant, beautiful, and truly unique jewelry. The designs are very simple, and suit a minimalist taste. I honestly can't get enough of their designs, and neither can many satisfied customers. Minimal VS has made over 30 thousand sales and has over 4000 reviews! 

Refund Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility

Shipping

• Ships worldwide.
• Current processing time for most solid gold items items is 8-9 weeks.
• Current processing time for most gold filled and sterling silver items is 1-3 weeks
• All items are shipped with fully insured express shipping. Delivery will take 2-10 business days, within Europe 1-3 business days.
• Buyers are responsible for all customs fees, taxes, or receiving fees incurred.

Warranty 

• 1 year warranty on jewelry. The warranty is voided if the items have been tampered with or have been subjected to physical injury. 

Minimal VS is available on Etsy, but they also have their very own website. It looks like you get a quicker production time if you shop their website, so I would recommend going there. 

Shop Clementine - Massachusetts, United States

Over 22,000 sales and 6000 reviews

What I love most about this shop is the selection of really affordable and beautiful options. Her use of unique stones cut in vintage styles is gorgeous and would suit any modern bride.  

Shop Clementine has been making jewelry since 2005 and selling on Etsy since 2006. She works with recycled silver and reclaimed gold, along with gemstones and diamonds, to make modern, minimalist jewelry. The owner, Cassie has studied metalwork at Snow Farm: The New England Craft Program; Metalwerx; and Penland School of Crafts.

Shop Clementine strives to use environmentally-friendly packaging, tools, and studio practices.

Refund Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.
• Accepts returns within 14 days after receipt, provided the item is in original condition and in its original packaging.
• Custom and personalized orders are not eligible for return.

Shipping

• See item details for estimated arrival times.
• Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply.

Warranty 

• I couldn't find any warranty information in the shop policies 

Mocha Rings - Toronto, Ontario

Over 21,000 sales and 3000 reviews

I love the sparkling wedding bands that Mocha Rings offers and I love how affordable their engagement rings are. Most rings are under $100. 

MochaRings creates custom rings by:
- Designing rings in CAD
- Make a wax model
- Casting (lost wax casting)
- Set stones, polish + plate the rings 
*They also set stones in wax so when they do so the ring is cast with the stones already in it*

Return Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

OORe - Washington, United States

Over 7000 sales and 1800 reviews

I love how pretty the rings are, with their colored gemstones, and the leaf band designs are stunning! Many of her rings are made with the highest quality lab-grown alexandrite. She also uses lots of sapphires in pretty lavender and ocean blue colors. Prices range from $1000 - $2000.

Uma Gordin of Oore makes jewelry inspired by nature. Her engagement rings are perfect for anyone looking for a unique engagement ring that offers something different than traditional. Oore has been active on Etsy since 2013, but Uma has been making jewelry since she was 18 years old. 

Return Policy

• Items need to be sent back within 7 days of arrival, in the same exact packaging it arrived in for a full refund. 

Shipping

• Current make time is around 8-9 weeks for most items
• Buyer is responsible for any import fees. 

Warranty

LaMore Design - New York, United States

Over 7000 sales and 1600 reviews

I love LaMore's section of men's wedding bands, she has some really unique ones with Celtic knotwork and stones. Her engagement rings are full of sparkle and she has many to choose from. I also love that LaMore offers a lifetime warranty service and her rings come with a Certificate of Authenticity at no extra charge. Prices are in the thousands of dollars. 

Annie of LaMore Design is a GIA Graduate Gemologist and jewelry designer. She has been designing jewelry for 13 years. She is skilled in both traditional jewelry design and advanced 3D design. She started making men's rings when her fiance could not find a unique ring for their wedding. 

Refund Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Shipping

• Average production time is around 3 weeks. 

Warranty 

• Guarantee that jewelry is free of any manufacturing defects in either materials or workmanship. If you have an issue with your purchase, please the shop. Their gemologist and jeweler will determine the cause of the damage, and, if it falls under their responsibility, they will repair the piece free of charge.

Rare earth - California, United States

Over 6000 sales and 1600 reviews

I love the many different fine gemstone options Rare Earth offers, from rubies, to sapphires, to diamonds. Rare Earth is a good shop for purchasing a more traditional style ring, but with the option to customize.

Rare Earth creates fine jewelry in gold, platinum, palladium and sterling silver. All of the diamonds used are conflict free, the gemstones Fair Trade, and 90% of the precious metals used are recycled and then refined for purity. Relationships with artisan miners and stone cutters allows Rare Earth access to top quality material at excellent prices, which is then reflected as affordable prices for you. 

Return Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Shipping

• All items ship via UPS or USPS with full value insurance, tracking and a signature required for delivery. 

Warranty

• All jewelry is guaranteed to be as described or your money back. In addition, all pieces are warranted for one year from date of purchase for any defects in materials or workmanship. The item may be returned for repair or replacement at no cost to you. Any modification, resizing or alteration by another jeweler will void this warranty.

Studio 1040 - California, United States

Over 3000 sales and 900 reviews

I love the elegant ring selection at Studio 1040 and her use of pink and peach sapphires.

Studio 1040's goal is for you to be fully satisfied and happy with your purchase. They treat every item as special and aim to sell fine jewelry at very affordable prices without compromising quality and style. ALL diamonds are ethically sourced and 100% conflict-free. Diamonds are only sourced from Kimberley certified diamond dealers.

Return Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Envero Jewelry - New York, United States

Over 8000 sales and 1800 reviews

Envero's opal jewelry is exquisite, and her use of diamonds is breathtaking! Many of her gemstones are rose cut, lending a vintage feel. Prices range from under $1000 to $3000 and up. 

The name "Envero" originated from a viticulture term- the transition of a berry from growth to ripening.

It's a literal expression of growth and maturity and creates a beautiful metaphor of the blossoming of young women. Just as the young, fresh, green berries mature into sweet, violet berries through stormy weather, strong young woman mature and grow through their life experiences and challenges. Kat's mission is to create jewelry which will accompany her through her life journey.

Return Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Shipping

• Made to Order is taking 6 weeks of production time.

Artemer - Tel Aviv, Isreal

Over 4500 sales and 900 reviews 

I love the truly unique designs available at Artemer - their use of triangles, squares, half-circles and various gemstones give their jewelry an uncommon aesthetic. Prices vary from $1000 and up.

Artemer makes handcrafted products with superior attention to detail and quality assurance - they design pieces to last a lifetime. Tomer and Tanya design and handcraft all the pieces themselves, having both graduated from the Bezalel Academy of Art and Design. Artemer aims to "create jewelry that is original, refined and beautiful, while not stealing the show from the person wearing it".  

Return Policy

• If you are unhappy with your purchase, let them know within 7 days after receiving the item. They will give you the return address and will refund the amount minus shipping once they receive the piece back.

Shipping

• Free delivery on most items

Warranty 

• 1-year warranty on all jewelry items purchased from Artemer. The warranty cover defects in craftsmanship or materials.
• Should your item get damaged after the expiration of the warranty period, they can repair the item as needed. Repair fees will vary, contact for details.

Doron Merav Jewelry - Tel Aviv, Isreal

Over 7000 sales and 1700 reviews

I love Doron's use of rough cut diamonds and his use of shapes and textures from nature. His jewelry is all about colors, textures and composition. Prices range from $500 and up.

A mixture of architecture design and jewelry. Doron uses 100% recycled gold and 100% conflict-free diamonds. All metals are available, as are all gemstones. Doron Marev's number one goal which is to be unique and different, while still making jewelry that is well made and comfortable to wear.

Return Policy

• See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Shipping

• Free delivery on most items.

Warranty 

• Doron offers a full one-year warranty. He doesn't have this info in his Etsy shop policies, so I emailed him to ask, and he got right back to me 🙂

Kate Szabone Fine Jewelry - Whitby, Ontario

Over 10,000 sales and 4000 reviews

I love Kate's vintage-inspired designs, they will never go out of style!  Kate specializes in custom engagement rings and wedding bands. Most engagement rings are in the $1000 range. 

Designs inspired by Art Nouveau and the simplicity and complexity of nature. Kate Szabone uses a range of natural gemstones and conflict-free diamonds, and utilizes custom-cut stones and unique designs. The metals she uses are recycled and ethically sourced. 

Return Policy

• Ready-to-Ship jewelry, not created as a custom order, may be returned for refund, credit or exchange within 7 days of receipt.
• Custom jewellery is a final sale.

Shipping

• See item details for estimated arrival times.
• Buyer is responsible for custom and import fees. 

Warranty

• Offer a free limited one year warranty against manufacturing defects on all jewelry. Warranty excludes coverage for wear and tear, loss of precious stones and theft.
• Repairs done by a 3rd party without approval will void warranty.

Rosodos Box - Illinois, United States

Over 15,000 sales and 2500 reviews 

I love that Rosodos Box donates a percentage of all of their earnings to charity foundations such as the Living Lands & Waters, Ronald McDonald House Charities, Purple Heart Homes, and C.A.S.L. You can feel good shopping here!

Rosodos Box focuses on pieces that are 100% American designed and crafted. They strive for quality of service and products at affordable prices. Stones are non-conflict/fair-traded and metals are recycled. Rosodos box has been featured on Buzzfeed, Glamour, MODWedding, Who What Wear and Bridal Guide to name a few. 

Rosodos box uses biodegradable solutions for cleaning their jewelry, recycle their paper, metals, and plastics as much as they can and all purchases come with a recyclable box and reusable/recyclable tote!

Return Policy

• Offers a 5-day money-back guarantee or exchange on all purchases (this excludes items that are custom-made, engraved, specialty sizes, rushed, discounted, and items on payment/financing plans). 

Shipping

• ALL UPS & FedEx PACKAGES REQUIRE ADULT SIGNATURE in order for package to be released + a phone number in case they need to reach you regarding your package. 

Warranty 

• 1 year limited warranty against any manufacturing defect. 

Love Forever Jewelry SV- United States 

Over 6000 sales and 2000 reviews

What I like most about Love Forever is their very flexible payment plans. 

Love Forever Jewelry specializes in custom diamond rings, white gold, yellow gold, rose gold, and more. They are perfect for special occasions, such as for a wedding or proposal. Love Forever can custom design anything you dream of. Their jewelry is 100% made in the USA.

Return Policy 

• Accepts returns and exchanges. Contact within 14 days of delivery.
• Custom items are non-refundable. 

Shipping

• FREE SHIPPING for United States Customers.
• Customs processes, import duties and sales taxes are the responsibility of the customer.

Warranty 

• Free one year warranty protecting against any defect resulting from its manufacture, wear, tear or damage. 

Tiger Gemstones - California, United States

Over 65,000 sales and 15,000 reviews 

I love all the sparkling rings available at Tiger Gemstones! And they are so affordable! Prices are in the $100 - $500 range. 

Tiger Gemstones uses the finest diamond simulant on the market, specially made for their products. Their diamond simulants are not natural diamonds, but are produced and cut specifically to replicate the beauty and sparkle of a perfect D color flawless natural diamond. They will not test as real, but will last a lifetime when properly cared for.  

Each piece is hand set in pre-mounted settings or entirely handcrafted. With amazing attention to detail, Tiger Gemstones individually inspects and selects every stone through the best cutters and laboratories in the world.

Return Policy

• Accepts the return of unworn merchandise in new condition within 30 days of the original ship date. Customers are responsible for return shipping fees. 

Shipping

• USPS Shipping Estimates:
  • Standard First Class Mail: 3-7 Business days, sometimes more.
  • Priority Mail: 2-5 Business days, sometimes more.
  • Express Shipping Options must be placed by Noon Eastern Time to go out the same day:
  • FedEx 2nd Day: 2 Business days guaranteed. Weekends and holidays are excluded.
  • FedEx Overnight: Next business day. Weekends and holidays are excluded.
• International Customers: Please note that delivery times are estimates only and we have no control over actual delivery times.
  • Standard international mail: 3-6 Weeks for delivery
  • Express International Mail: Approximately 10 days for most countries. Canada is 2-3 days.
• Customs charges, VAT and duty fees are the responsibility of the customer and are not included in the price or shipping charges of the item.

Conclusion

There you have it! 15 of THE BEST shops on Etsy for purchasing the ring of your dreams. 

What shop is your favorite? Would you add any to the list? Leave a comment below because we would love to hear it! Remember to share this post on your social media so your friends can benefit, we would appreciate it so much. 

Bonus Shops that we also Love:

Congrats on Your Love,
Andrea