• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Best Etsy Shops for Vintage Engagement Rings
best etsy shops for vintage engagment rings

You are here because you want to buy a vintage engagement ring for your beloved on Etsy. And I am happy to say that I am here to help you on that journey. 🙂 I have researched for you and found the best Etsy shops for vintage engagement rings.

Etsy has soooo many fabulous finds, and vintage engagement rings are no exception. I spend a lot of time on Etsy, and I have ordered many items from this beautiful site. Etsy is a pleasurable site to browse, and there is a plethora of gorgeous handmade and vintage items. Because of the vast selection available, it can sometimes be overwhelming to sift through all the options to find an exceptional Etsy shop.

The shops that I recommend offer excellent customer service and have hundreds of happy customers. All of the engagement rings carried by these Etsy sellers are absolutely exquisite.

[Read: How to buy an Engagement Ring on Etsy]

My Recommended Shops meet these requirements:

  • Over 1000 sales
  • Over 500 5-star reviews
  • Over 2000 people have them as a favorite shop

The 8 Best Etsy Shops For Vintage Engagement Rings

Vintage Engagement Rings by MSJewelers on Etsy

Ms Jewelers - New Hampshire, United States

Over 13000 sales and 4400 reviews

MS Jewelers carries exceptional quality vintage jewelry, including engagement rings, wedding bands, charms, cocktail rings, necklaces, brooches, etc. Their photos and descriptions are excellent and include all the information you need to know exactly what you are purchasing. 

Each piece has been identified and graded by a Graduate Gemologist who has been certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA)

Market Square Jewelers was built on a love for the unusually beautiful. Whether we are seeking the most breathtaking Victorian lavalier, the bluest Sri Lankan sapphire, or an eclectic and handcrafted silver bangle, we approach the search like a quest, like a challenge. Regarded by many customers as “The Library of Jewelry”, we attempt to represent not only a variety of stylistic time periods and unusual gemstones, but a variety of price ranges as well.

Refund Policy

  • Contact within 7 days of delivery and send item back within 14 days of delivery. 
  • You have 24 hours to request a cancellation. 
  • When returning an item, you are asked to insure the package for its purchased value and to package the jewelry carefully so the item is not damaged in transition.
  • After the 10 day return window, they also do offer an exchange for store credit within 30 days of the purchase date.

Shipping

  • Packages will be shipped within 1-5 business days after payment is received. All packages are insured for their purchase price, with signature required for delivery confirmation.
  • Most packages will be sent through USPS.
  • INTERNATIONAL CUSTOMERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL DUTIES, TAXES AND FEES ASSOCIATED WITH CUSTOMS.
  • At this time, MS Jewelers cannot ship to Russia.

Additional Policies

  • SIZING: All rings over $1,000.00 USD are sized at no charge to the customer. If a ring needs to go down or up more than one size, please contact MS Jewelers before purchasing it to make sure it is possible. If a ring is less than $1,000, please contact for sizing quote.
  • ENGRAVING: Offer hand-engraving services for an additional fee. Contact for quote. 

Drool-Worthy Rings

Mid Century Diamond Engagement Ring with Antique Patina

Mid Century Diamond Engagement Ring with Antique Patina

Pink Sapphire Diamond White Gold Engagement Ring

Pink Sapphire Diamond White Gold Engagement Ring

Indigo Blue Sapphire Gemstone set in a Vintage Leaf and Berry

Indigo Blue Sapphire Gemstone set in a Vintage Leaf and Berry


Antique and Vintage Engagement Rings by YourJewelryFinder on Etsy


Your Jewelry Finder - Maryland, United States

Over 2600 sales and 840 reviews

Your Jewelry Finder provides pre-loved quality fine jewelry in the hopes that you will find a special piece of jewelry to touch your heart.  "Something Old" stands for continuity and tradition. "Something New" represents optimism and success. "Something You" is a reflection and a piece of who you are, and what you find valuable.

Your Jewelry Finder offers layaway and flexible payment plans. Every piece is tested appraised by an unbiased and completely independent graduate gemologist NAJA member (National Association Of Jewelry Appraisers).  The shop includes detailed descriptions of every piece, precise measurements, YouTube videos, and multiple authentic and clear photos.

Refund Policy

  • For returns, contact within 3 days of delivery and ship item back within 7 days of delivery. 
  • Request a cancellation within 1 hour of purchase. 
  • Buyer is responsible for return shipping. Re-sized, layaway or altered pieces cannot be returned or exchanged.

Shipping

  • FAST & FREE domestic USPS Priority Mail Express, Insured, & Adult Signature Required in the US.
  • Does not ship internationally at this time. 

Additional Policies

  • Sizing: All rings except eternity bands can be re-sized by a trusted independent bench jeweler. Ring re-sizing takes an additional 1-10 business days depending on the workload. On average it takes 2-5 days.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Vintage Art Deco Engagement Ring

Vintage Art Deco Engagement Ring

Antique Victorian Solitaire Engagement Ring

Antique Victorian Solitaire Engagement Ring

White Gold Vintage Art Deco Diamond Filigree Ring

White Gold Vintage Art Deco Diamond Filigree Ring


Vintage Engagment Rings by GourmetVintage on Etsy

Gourmet Vintage - Florida, United States

Over 1800 sales and 500 reviews

Gourmet Vintage offers a cornucopia of the finest gold and silver jewelry. They specialize in Art Deco and Georgian Engagement Rings, Antique Signet Rings, and Tribal Silver Jewelry.

Gourmet Vintage offers layaway and flexible payment plans. Every piece is hand selected and inspected before they are listed.

Refund Policy

  • For returns, contact within 3 days of delivery, and ship back within 7 days of delivery. 
  • Request cancellation within 1 hour of purchase. 
  • Items purchased at $0 - $500 will be accepted for returns if you contact us within 3 days of receipt. They will provide a store credit for the item once it has been returned.
  • Items purchased over $501 dollars will be accepted for returns.
  • All items that are returned will be refunded minus the amount of shipping even if the original order includes free shipping. 

Shipping

  • All items purchased through Gourmet Vintage will be shipped within 5-7 business days (or as specified on the listing) with a tracking number.
  • Depending on your global location delivery may take anywhere from 1-4 weeks.
  • If you would like to purchase insurance to cover loss for items under $1,000 or if you require expedited shipping arrangements please contact before purchase.
  • Seller is not responsible for customs charges, tax, losses, or damages caused by the postal service unless it is covered by insurance.

Additional Policies

  • Offer both flexible layaway and payment plans.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Victorian diamond cluster halo ring

Victorian diamond cluster halo ring

Georgian engagement ring

Georgian engagement ring

Navette ruby and diamond ring

Navette ruby and diamond ring


vintage engagement rings by CypressCreekVintage on Etsy

Cypress Creek Vintage - Oklahoma, United States

Over 3500 sales and 1000 reviews

At Cypress Creek Vintage, you can shop with safety and confidence. All gems and metals are authenticated and guaranteed, and they are one of the antique shops that accept returns. Enjoy fast shipping! Cypress Creek takes great care with their packaging presentation for safe shipping and gift-giving.  

Cypress Creek Vintage offer a layaway program and has detailed descriptions and photos of each piece. They also have videos of many of their rings so you can see their sparkle.

Return Policy

  • Returns will be accepted within 3 days of delivery, and send item back within 7 days of delivery. 
  • Doesn't accept exchanges or cancellations, but please contact if you have any problems with your order.
  • Shipping costs are nonrefundable.
  • Any ring that has been sized or altered is not eligible for a return.

Shipping

  • Handling time is usually same-day but can take up to 3 days before shipment. Upon shipment, customers receive an email with tracking information from Etsy.
  • Shipping will be USPS Priority for international orders. 
  • The customer is responsible for all duties, taxes, associated with Customs.

Additional Policies

  • Does not include any paper work with your purchase. They DO offer gemological appraisal for an additional fee in the shop.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Antique Toi et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring in 18k Gold

Antique Toi et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring in 18k Gold

Antique Sapphire Diamond Crown Heart Ring

Antique Sapphire Diamond Crown Heart Ring

Antique Cognac Diamond Trilogy Ring in 18k Gold

Antique Cognac Diamond Trilogy Ring in 18k Gold


Affordable Vintage Engagement Rings by boylerpf on Etsy

Boylerpf - North Dakota, United States

Over 2000 sales and 3500 reviews

Boylerpf offers fine antique Victorian jewelry, Edwardian jewelry, Art Nouveau and Art Deco jewelry, Engagement rings and Estate jewelry including necklaces, bracelets, brooches, rings and earrings!

Boylerpf offers a layaway program. Each piece they list has been professionally examined and verbally appraised as well as being tested by a goldsmith for metal content. This shop ships worldwide. 

Return Policy

  • For returns, contact within 3 days of delivery, ship within 7 days of delivery.
  • Doesn't accept exchanges or cancellations, but please contact if you have any problems with your order.
  • All items should be returned in the original condition and packaging sent, insured, postmarked within 7 business days after receiving the package in the mail.
  • Buyer pays for all shipping costs.
  • Can not accept returns or issue refunds of any kind if the piece has been altered by another jeweler or damaged in the process of testing.

Shipping

  • US First Class Shipping - Free
  • US Priority Shipping - $8.25
  • US Express Shipping - $29.00

  • International First Class - $18
  • International Priority - $38.25
  • International Express - $68.25
  • All US purchases are shipped within 24 hours of payment barring weekends and holidays.
  • Import duties, taxes, and related charges are not included in the price and are a responsibility of the buyer. 

Additional Policies

  • Re-sizing: $60 for sizing up or down a whole size.
  • Certification:  Descriptions are written with verbal information given from a GIA gemologist who has inspected the piece. They can have an item sent for an appraisal at an additional non-refundable cost.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Antique Diamond Engagement Ring 18K Gold Diamond Cluster

Antique Diamond Engagement Ring 18K Gold Diamond Cluster

Vintage 18K Gold Diamond Halo Citrine Ring

Vintage 18K Gold Diamond Halo Citrine Ring

Antique Diamond Emerald Engagement Ring 18K Gold Solitaire

Antique Diamond Emerald Engagement Ring 18K Gold Solitaire


Antique Vintage Engagment Rings by TrademarkAntiques on Etsy

Trademark Antiques - Pennsylvania, United States

Over 3700 sales and 1300 reviews

Trademark Antiques offers fine antique & vintage jewelry and uniquely designed conversion jewelry. Their conversion jewelry line incorporates antique and vintage jewelry components in fresh and exciting new ways.

One of the owners is a GIA Applied Jewelry Professional and chemist who evaluates all gemstones using standard gem analysis techniques. They also acquire gemstone analysis reports and appraisals from outside gem labs for some of their more valuable gemstone pieces.

Trademark Antiques offers layaway plans and all packages are fully insured.  

Refund Policy

  • For returns, contact within 3 days of delivery, ship within 7 days of delivery.
  • Doesn't accept exchanges or cancellations, but please contact if you have any problems with your order.

Shipping

  • Ships all domestic orders via USPS Priority mail with signature confirmation and insurance, unless otherwise specified at check out. 
  • Ships to most countries in the world. Customs, duties, fees and any import taxes are the responsibility of buyer, as are any return shipping costs.
  • All packages are fully insured.

Warranty 

  • Re-Sizing: Ring sizing services are available FREE of charge by an expert jeweler. Sizing generally takes 2 to 5 business days. You can return a ring that has been re-sized by their in house jeweler for a full refund.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

Sapphire & Diamond Crowned Heart Ring 18k White Gold

Sapphire & Diamond Crowned Heart Ring 18k White Gold

Antique Champagne Diamond Ring 18k Gold

Antique Champagne Diamond Ring 18k Gold


Vintage Engagement Rings by Gold Adore on Etsy

Gold Adore - California, United States

Over 7400 sales and 2400 reviews

Gold Adore offers a carefully curated selection of affordable Fine Vintage Jewelry and Handcrafted Fine Jewelry. They are committed to helping their customers find beautiful, authentic pieces of gorgeous fine jewelry. With a GIA Graduate Gemologist and Master Jeweler on staff, they can guarantee all of their items are fully inspected, authenticated, and accurately described.

Return Policy

  • For returns, contact within 5 days of delivery, and ship item back within 7 days of delivery. 
  • Accepts cancellations within 1 hour of purchase. 
  • Buyers are responsible for return postage costs.

Shipping

  • All items (excluding custom designs/sizings) will ship next business day after order, and ship via USPS Priority Mail, with Signature Confirmation.
  • All items are fully tracked and insured.

Additional Policies

  • Re-Sizing:  charge $50 for Regular Gold Sizing (up or down 2 sizes), and $60 for Regular Platinum Sizing.
  • Offer free appraisals with any purchase.
  • Most basic maintenance services are also offered free of charge (you just pay shipping!).

Drool-Worthy Rings

Vintage 14K Yellow Gold Diamond and Emerald Halo Ring

Vintage 14K Yellow Gold Diamond and Emerald Halo Ring

Vintage 14K Yellow Gold Star Sapphire and Diamond Ring

Vintage 14K Yellow Gold Star Sapphire and Diamond Ring

Vintage Halo 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Ruby Ring Engagement Ring

Vintage Halo 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Ruby Ring Engagement Ring


Antique Vintage Engagement Rings by DiamondAddiction on Etsy

Diamond ADDICTION - California, United States

Over 4500 sales and 1600 reviews

Diamond Addiction is adding new rings everyday! They offer flexible layaway and payment plans. All jewelry has been verbally authenticated by a gemologist or by the shops bench jeweler.

Return Policy

  • For returns, contact within 3 days of delivery, ship back within 7 days of delivery.
  • Request cancellation before item is dispatched. 

Shipping

  • All shipping in the USA will be done by USPS Priority Insured 2-3 day.
  • All International shipping will be done by USPS Priority Insured, USPS Express International insured, UPS or FedEx.

Drool-Worthy Rings

Antique Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring Old Mine Cut Diamond

Antique Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring Old Mine Cut Diamond

Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring

Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring

Antique Pink Sapphire Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Antique Pink Sapphire Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring


Conclusion

There you have it! 8 of THE BEST shops on Etsy for purchasing a vintage engagement rings.  

What shop is your favorite? Would you add any to the list? Leave a comment below because we would love to hear it! Remember to share this post on your social media so your friends can benefit, we would appreciate it so much. 

Congrats on Your Love,
Andrea

Spread the love

About the Author

Andrea

I am here to help you find the best vintage jewelry!

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

  1. Hi Andrea. I’m a fan of vintage jewelry. I have some rings and earrings. You presented the 8 very elaborate stores. Their return policies, deadline, possibility of adjustment etc. Impressive. You can see that you like vintage rings if you have made such an elaborate post. Congratulations.

  2. Choosing the right engagement ring is definitely a task that must be done very carefully. The problem for many people is that they do not have enough experience, time, or budget to make such a choice. I am amazed to find in these options that you offer us so many possibilities to choose between different precious rings and at really very affordable prices. Best of all, they have the backing of a site with such a good reputation as Etsy.

  3. Yes I have heard a lot about your jewellery finder and though it was not much that I heard about them, but then it was much enough to know that they offer such quality rings. A colleague of mine has tried them and had gotten a very great one. Hence, since my kid sister is getting married in some weeks now, I want to get a very good pair for them and this place would be just perfect to get that from. Thanks for the listing

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Related Posts